By-elections in New Zealand occur to fill vacant seats in the New Zealand Parliament. The death, resignation, or expulsion of a sitting electorate MP can cause a by-election. (Note that list MPs do not have geographic districts for the purpose of provoking by-elections – if a list MP's seat becomes vacant, the next person on his or her party's list fills the position.)
A by-election need not take place if a general election will occur within six months of an electorate seat becoming vacant. In 1996 the general election date was brought forward slightly, to 12 October, to avoid a by-election after the resignation of Michael Laws.
In recent years by-elections have not occurred particularly frequently – only one in the 2002–2005 parliamentary term, and none in the 1999–2002 or 2005–2008 terms. This is because most MPs who retire mid-term (e.g. Labour MPs Jim Sutton and Michael Cullen) were List MPs, and are simply replaced by the next member on their party list.
Historically, however, they have taken place considerably more frequently – the 2nd Parliament of 1856–1860, for example, saw 33 by-elections and four supplementary elections, despite the House of Representatives originally having just 37 seats (increasing to 41 seats during the parliamentary term).
In the past it was not uncommon for an MP who died in office to be replaced with an immediate family member such as a brother, wife (see widow's succession), or son. This resulted in the election of the first woman MP Elizabeth McCombs (who was in turn succeeded by her son Terence McCombs) and the first woman National MP Mary Grigg; both of whom took over their husband's seat. This practice has however fallen out of favour since the mid-seventies with the election of John Kirk to his late father's seat being the last occasion this happened at a by-election.
Eleven Prime Ministers first came to parliament via by-elections: Julius Vogel, Harry Atkinson, Robert Stout, John Ballance, William Massey, Peter Fraser, Keith Holyoake, Walter Nash, Bill Rowling, David Lange and Geoffrey Palmer. Five Prime Ministers (William Fox, Henry Sewell, Edward Stafford, George Grey and Joseph Ward) have won by-elections later in their parliamentary careers, while Labour leader Harry Holland was also first elected via a by-election. Some minor party founders have also launched their parties by resigning from a major party and their seat, then contesting it for their new party. Party founders who have done this include Matiu Rata and Tariana Turia. Interestingly, both resigned from Labour to form Māori parties. In 1980 Rata was unsuccessful in retaking his Northern Maori electorate for his newly formed Mana Motuhake party, but in 2004 Turia successfully reclaimed Te Tai Hauauru for the Maori Party. In addition, Winston Peters resigned from National and his parliamentary seat in 1993, retaking the seat as an independent and going on to form the New Zealand First party. In these circumstances, by-elections are seen as a legitimisation of the MP's rejection of his or her old party. In addition, they provide vital publicity and something of a mandate for the new party.
26th Parliament (1939–1943) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1939 Christchurch South | 3 June 1939 | Death of Ted Howard (Labour) | Robert Macfarlane (Labour) |
1940 Auckland West | 18 May 1940 | Death of Michael Joseph Savage (Labour) | Peter Carr (Labour) |
1940 Waipawa | 16 November 1940 | Death of Albert Jull | Cyril Geoffrey Edmund Harker (National) |
1941 Waitemata | 19 July 1941 | Death of William John Lyon (Labour) | Mary Manson Dreaver (Labour) |
1941 Bay of Plenty | 13 December 1941 | Death of Gordon Hultquist (Labour) | William Sullivan (National) |
1942 Mid-Canterbury | 27 January 1942 | Death of Arthur Nattle Grigg (National) | Mary Victoria Cracroft Grigg (National) |
1942 Temuka | 7 February 1942 | Death of Thomas David Burnett | Hugh John Dyke Ackland (National) |
1942 Hauraki | 7 February 1942 | Death of John Manchester Allen (National) | Andrew Sinclair Sutherland (National) |
1943 Christchurch East | 6 February 1943 | Death of Tim Armstrong (Labour) | Mabel Howard (Labour) |
1943 Northern Maori | 1943 | Death of Paraire Karaka Paikea (Labour) | Tapihana Paraire Paikea (Labour) |
27th Parliament (1943–1946) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1944 Awarua | 28 October 1944 | Death of James Hargest (National) | George Richard Herron (National) |
1945 Western Maori | 10 February 1945 | Death of Haami Tokouru Ratana (Labour) | Matiu Ratana (Labour) |
1945 Hamilton | 26 May 1945 | Death of Frank Findlay (National) | Grace Hilda Ross (National) |
1945 Dunedin North | 21 July 1945 | Death of James Wright Munro | Robert Walls (Labour) |
1946 Raglan | 5 March 1946 | Death of Robert Coulter (Labour) | Hallyburton Johnstone (National) |
28th Parliament (1946–1949) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1947 Avon | 28 May 1947 | Death of Daniel Giles Sullivan (Labour) | John Mathison (Labour) |
1947 Mount Albert | 24 September 1947 | Death of Arthur Shapton Richards (Labour) | Warren Freer (Labour) |
1947 Westland | 3 December 1947 | Death of James O'Brien (Labour) | James Begg Kent (Labour) |
29th Parliament (1950–1951) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1951 Brooklyn | 17 February 1951 | Death of Peter Fraser (Labour) | Arnold Nordmeyer (Labour) |
30th Parliament (1951–1954) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1953 Dunedin North | 12 December 1953 | Death of Robert Walls (Labour) | Ethel McMillan (Labour) |
1953 Onehunga | 19 December 1953 | Death of Arthur Osborne (Labour) | Hugh Watt (Labour) |
1954 Onslow | 7 July 1954 | Death of Harry Ernest Combs (Labour) | Henry May (Labour) |
1954 Patea | 31 July 1954 | Resignation of William Alfred Sheat (National) | Roy Jack (National) |
31st Parliament (1955–1957) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1956 Riccarton | 27 October 1956 | Death of Angus Mclagan (Labour) | Mick Connelly (Labour) |
1957 Bay of Plenty | 6 April 1957 | Resignation of William Sullivan | Percy Allen (National) |
32nd Parliament (1958–1960) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1959 Hamilton | 2 May 1959 | Death of Grace Hilda Ross (National) | Lancelot (Lance) Adams-Schneider (National) |
33rd Parliament (1961–1963) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1961 Hurunui | 10 June 1961 | Death of William Henry Gillespie | Herbert Elmer Lorraine Pickering (National) |
1962 Waitaki | 10 March 1962 | Death of Thomas Hayman | Allan Dick (National) |
1962 Buller | 7 July 1962 | Death of Jerry Skinner (Labour) | Bill Rowling (Labour) # |
1962 Timaru | 21 July 1962 | Resignation of Rev. Clyde Carr (Labour) | Basil Arthur (Labour) |
1963 Otahuhu | 16 March 1963 | Death of James Deas | Bob Tizard (Labour) |
1963 Northern Maori | 16 March 1963 | Death of Tapihana Paraire Paikea | Matiu Rata (Labour) |
1963 Grey Lynn | 18 May 1963 | Death of Fred Hackett | Reginald Alfred Keeling (Labour) |
34th Parliament (1964–1966) |
|||
There were no by-elections during the term of the 34th Parliament.[38] | |||
35th Parliament (1967–1969) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1967 Southern Maori | 11 March 1967 | Death of Eruera Tirikatene | Whetu Tirikatene-Sullivan (Labour) |
1967 Fendalton | 15 April 1967 | Death of Harry Lake | Eric Holland (National) |
1967 Petone | 15 April 1967 | Death of Michael Moohan | Fraser Colman (Labour) |
1967 Palmerston North | 2 December 1967 | Death of Bill Brown | Joe Walding (Labour) |
1967 Eastern Maori | 12 December 1967 | Death of Puti Tipene Watene | Paraone Reweti (Labour) |
1968 Hutt | 3 August 1968 | Death of Walter Nash (Labour) | Trevor James Young (Labour) |
36th Parliament (1970–1972) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1970 Marlborough | 21 February 1970 | Death of Tom Shand | Ian James Brooks (Labour) |
37th Parliament (1973–1975) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1974 Sydenham | 2 November 1974 | Death of Norman Kirk | John Kirk (Labour) |
38th Parliament (1976–1978) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1976 Nelson | 28 February 1976 | Death of Stanley Whitehead | Mel Courtney (Labour) |
1977 Mangere | 26 March 1977 | Resignation of Colin Moyle (Labour) | David Lange (Labour) # |
1977 Pahiatua | 30 April 1977 | Sir Keith Holyoake appointed as Governor-General | John Falloon (National) |
1978 Rangitikei | 18 February 1978 | Death of Sir Roy Jack | Bruce Beetham (Social Credit) |
39th Parliament (1979–1981) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1979 Christchurch Central | 18 August 1979 | Death of Bruce Barclay (Labour) | Geoffrey Palmer (Labour) # |
1980 Northern Maori | 7 June 1980 | Resignation of Matiu Rata (was Labour) | Bruce Gregory (Labour) |
1980 Onehunga | 7 June 1980 | Death of Frank Lewis Rogers (Labour) | Fred Gerbic (Labour) |
1980 East Coast Bays | 6 September 1980 | Appointment of Frank Gill as Ambassador to the United States |
Gary Knapp (Social Credit) |
40th Parliament (1982–1984) |
|||
There were no by-elections during the term of the 40th Parliament.[38] | |||
41st Parliament (1984–1987) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1985 Timaru | 15 June 1985 | Death of Basil Arthur (Labour) | Maurice McTigue (National) |
42nd Parliament (1987–1990) |
|||
There were no by-elections during the term of the 42nd Parliament. | |||
43rd Parliament (1990–1993) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1992 Tamaki | 15 February 1992 | Retirement of Robert Muldoon (National) | Clem Simich (National) |
1992 Wellington Central | 12 December 1992 | Election of sitting MP Fran Wilde (Labour) to Mayoralty of Wellington |
Chris Laidlaw (Labour) |
1993 Tauranga | 17 April 1993 | Resignation of Winston Peters from the National Party | Winston Peters (Independent) |
44th Parliament (1994–1996) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1994 Selwyn | 13 August 1994 | Resignation of Ruth Richardson (National) | David Carter (National)[79] |
45th Parliament (1997–1999) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
1998 Taranaki-King Country | 2 May 1998 | Resignation of Jim Bolger (National) | Shane Ardern (National)[80] |
46th Parliament (2000–2002) |
|||
There were no by-elections during the term of the 46th Parliament. | |||
47th Parliament (2003–2005) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
2004 Te Tai Hauauru | 10 July 2004 | Resignation of Tariana Turia from the Labour Party | Tariana Turia (Māori Party)[81] |
48th Parliament (2006–2008) |
|||
There were no by-elections during the term of the 48th Parliament. | |||
49th Parliament (2009–2011) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
2009 Mount Albert | 13 June 2009 | Resignation of Helen Clark (Labour) | David Shearer (Labour)[82] |
2010 Mana | 20 November 2010 | Resignation of Winnie Laban (Labour) | Kris Faafoi (Labour)[83] |
2011 Botany | 5 March 2011 | Resignation of Pansy Wong (National) | Jami-Lee Ross (National) |
2011 Te Tai Tokerau | 25 June 2011 | Resignation of Hone Harawira (Independent) | Hone Harawira (Mana Party) |
50th Parliament (2012 – present) |
|||
By-election | Date | Reason | Winner |
There have been no by-elections during the term of the 50th Parliament yet. |
|